kringo

Retrospective formats and an intervision method: 4 you can run from one screen

Whoever leads a retro or an intervision session does three jobs at once: asks the next question, watches the time, and notices who has not spoken yet. The first two can go on the wall. Each of the 4 formats here puts its steps and its clock on a screen the whole group sees, with the method’s source beside it, and leaves the third job to you, along with the decision when to move on.

In the room that screen is on the wall, in a video call you share it, and everyone joins from a phone with a first name.

Choose a format

A format is the order of a conversation

A retrospective looks back at a stretch of work so the team can change one thing in the next. An intervision session helps one colleague with a question from their work, with the group as the thinking partner. Both are conversations that happen again and again, and both go flat when they have no order: the same three people talk, time runs out before anything is decided.

A format gives the conversation an order: a few steps, a question per step, a number of minutes. The formats here are not ours. Each one comes from people who described it, and their names stand beside it. What we add is the screen that carries the steps, so the person who leads this time can look at the group.

How a session runs

Every format on this page runs the same way, whatever its steps are.

  1. You open the session: choose the format and put the screen where the group can see it: on the wall in the room, or shared in Zoom or Teams.
  2. The group joins: by scanning the code or typing six digits. No account, only a first name.
  3. The screen shows one step at a time: its question and its clock. Everyone writes a few words on their phone first, then you talk round the circle.
  4. People mark when they are ready: and the ring on the screen fills. You see when the group is done before the clock says so.
  5. You move on: the clock never does that for you. You pause it, add a minute or take one off when the group needs it.
  6. You end with who does what, by when: action ideas caught during the steps are waiting on the last screen, to be finished or dropped.

After you close the session kringo keeps nothing that was written, only numbers such as how long each step ran and how many people joined. You download the summary if you want to keep the actions and the notes.

Which format for which meeting

The minutes are the method’s own. Add ten for arriving and for the actions at the end.

  • Start Stop Continue

    Names what to start, what to stop and what to keep doing.

    The team is new to retros, or you have half an hour. · 21 min · 3–10

  • 4Ls

    Looks back through four words: liked, learned, lacked, longed for.

    A project or a quarter has ended and there is something to learn from it. · 24 min · 3–10

  • Sailboat

    Names the wind that pushes the team and the anchors that hold it, then chooses one change.

    The team feels slow and nobody has said why. · 20 min · 3–10

  • Incident method

    One person tells a moment from their work without its ending; the group analyses before hearing what happened.

    A peer group meets to learn from each other’s cases. · 38 min · 4–8

The four, one paragraph each

Start Stop Continue

Three questions, the same minutes for each. It asks for behaviour, so the answers are already close to actions: something we start, something we stop, something we keep. A good first retro for a team, and a good one when time is short. Start Stop Continue, step by step.

4Ls

Four words that make room for more than problems. “Learned” and “longed for” bring out things a list of complaints never reaches. It fits the end of something: a release, a project, a year. 4Ls, step by step.

Sailboat

A picture instead of a list: the team is a boat, something fills its sails and something drags behind it. People who stay quiet with a direct question often speak through the picture. The last step asks for one change, not five. Sailboat, step by step.

Incident method

The Dutch intervision classic. The case owner tells one concrete moment and stops before the ending. The group asks for facts, analyses, and says what they would have done; only then does the case owner tell what happened. Nobody can argue from the outcome, because nobody knows it. Incident method, step by step.

If this is your first time leading

Take Start Stop Continue. Open the session ten minutes early and try it with your own phone as the only participant, so you have seen every screen once before the group does.

In the meeting, say one sentence about the order and start. You do not have to explain the method: each step is on the screen when its turn comes. Your work is the group: who has not spoken yet, and whether this step is done.

What goes wrong in these meetings

  • The talkers fill the time.

    Everyone writes a few words first, on their own phone. Then you go round the circle, and each person has something to say.

  • You look at the clock, not at people.

    The clock is on the wall for everyone. When it reaches zero nothing happens until you decide.

  • The meeting ends without a decision.

    The last screen asks who does what, by when, before you close.

  • The retro is the same every sprint.

    Change the format, keep the routine: the group joins the same way and the screen works the same way.

  • In intervision, advice comes too early.

    The incident method holds advice back by its order: facts first, then analysis, and the ending last.

  • Online, half the group drifts off.

    Each person has the step in their hand and marks when they are ready, so you see who is still with you.

Questions before a first session

Do participants need an account?

No. They scan the code or type six digits at kringo.club and give a first name. Only the person who hosts signs in.

Does it work in Zoom or Teams?

Yes. You share the screen in the call the way you would share slides, and people join from their phones. In the room you put the same screen on the wall. A mixed group does both at once.

Can I change the minutes?

Yes, during the session. Each step starts with the method’s minutes, and you add or take off a minute at a time, or pause the clock. The clock never moves the group to the next step. You do.

What does kringo keep after the session?

Nothing that was written. After you close, the notes, the actions and the first names are gone from kringo; what stays are numbers, such as the method, how long each step ran and how many people joined. If you want the actions and notes, you download the summary before you close.

How many people can join?

The formats are made for a team or a peer group: three to ten people for a retro, four to eight for the incident method. With more people the round of the circle no longer fits in the minutes.

Are these your own methods?

No. Each format names the people who described it, and the list of sources is below. The step names and questions on the screen are our wording of their method.

Sources

  • Esther Derby & Diana Larsen, Agile Retrospectives: Making Good Teams Great, Pragmatic Bookshelf, 2006.
  • Mary Gorman & Ellen Gottesdiener, The 4L’s: A Retrospective Technique, EBG Consulting.
  • Luke Hohmann, the Speedboat exercise, 2006; the sailboat retrospective is the form agile teams gave it.
  • Jeroen Hendriksen, Intervisie bij werk en opleiding.

Written by Oksana Oliinyk ·

All formats

  • Start Stop Continue

    after Esther Derby & Diana Larsen, Agile Retrospectives (2006)

    21 min

  • 4Ls

    after Mary Gorman & Ellen Gottesdiener (2012)

    24 min

  • Sailboat

    after Luke Hohmann’s Speedboat (2006)

    20 min

  • Incident method

    after Jeroen Hendriksen, Intervisie bij werk en opleiding

    38 min