kringo

Retrospective

4Ls

4 steps, 24 min · Method after Mary Gorman & Ellen Gottesdiener (2012)

At the end of a project people carry more than a list of problems: something went well, something was learned, something was missing all along. 4Ls gives each of those its own turn, with a fourth for what the team wished it had. The screen the group sees, on the wall or shared in a video call, shows one word at a time with its clock, and you lead the talk rather than the timetable.

Start this sessionSign in to host. Participants need no account, only a first name.

The steps

  1. 1LikedWhat did you like?5 min
  2. 2LearnedWhat did you learn?5 min
  3. 3LackedWhat was lacking?6 min
  4. 4Longed forWhat did you long for?8 min

These are the method’s minutes. During the session you add or take off a minute when the group needs it.

Roles

Facilitator
Leads the session, gives the word round the circle and decides when to move on.
Note-taker
Catches action ideas as you talk, one line each.

What the group sees

The shared screen: the step, its question, the roles and the clock, with a dot for everyone who joined.
Each phone: the same step, a note, and “I’m ready”.

When 4Ls fits

Pick it when something has ended: a release, a project, a quarter, a year. There is a whole stretch of work to look at, and people feel several things about it at once. The four words let them say the good and the missing side by side.

It also helps a team that is tired of listing problems. Two of the four questions cannot be answered with a complaint. For an ordinary sprint with half an hour, Start Stop Continue is lighter.

Leading it, word by word

Liked. An easy start. Ask for something concrete: a moment, a decision, a piece of help from a colleague. “The atmosphere” is true and tells the team nothing.

Learned. Often the quietest step, because people have to think. Let the writing time run; silence here is work. What someone learned may be about the product, about the team or about themselves.

Lacked. Looks back: what was missing that we needed? Keep it on the thing that was missing, not on the person who should have brought it.

Longed for. Looks forward: what do we wish we had next time? Most actions come from this step, so the note-taker has the most to catch here.

Three things to watch

  • “Lacked” and “longed for” blur. Say the difference in one sentence before the third step: lacked is what we missed, longed for is what we wish for.
  • Four rounds take long. With eight people or more, ask each person for their one most important note per word, not all of them.
  • A warm ending without a decision. 4Ls leaves a good feeling. Use the last screen to turn one or two wishes into who does what, by when.

Where it comes from

Mary Gorman and Ellen Gottesdiener of EBG Consulting described the 4Ls as a retrospective technique for iterations and projects. The four words are theirs; the questions on the screen are our wording.

Other methods