kringo

Intervision

Incident method

8 steps, 38 min · Method after Jeroen Hendriksen, Intervisie bij werk en opleiding

In most peer groups the advice arrives before the story is finished. The incident method prevents that by its order: a colleague tells one moment from their work and stops before the ending, and the group analyses it without knowing how it went. You lead with the steps, the question and the time on a screen everyone sees, in the room or shared in a video call. It is one of the best-known methods of Dutch intervision, the peer groups in which colleagues learn from each other’s cases.

Start this sessionSign in to host. Participants need no account, only a first name.

The steps

  1. 1The questionCase owner: what is your question to this group? One sentence, no story yet.3 min
  2. 2The incidentTell one concrete moment. Stop before how it ended.4 min
  3. 3ClarifyAsk about the facts, not why. Stay away from the ending.3 min
  4. 4AnalysisWhat is really going on here? The case owner listens.10 min
  5. 5AlternativesWrite first: what would you do, and from what stance? Then tell it briefly.7 min
  6. 6ResponseCase owner: what did you do, or what will you do? Questions to understand, no debate.3 min
  7. 7InsightsIn turn: which insight do you take with you? About yourself, not advice.5 min
  8. 8ReflectionAbout the session, not the case: where did it get sharp, what do we change next time?3 min

These are the method’s minutes. During the session you add or take off a minute when the group needs it.

Roles

Case owner
Brings the case: asks the question and tells the incident without its ending.
Facilitator
Leads the session, gives the word round the circle and decides when to move on.
Note-taker
Catches action ideas as you talk, one line each.

What the group sees

The shared screen: the step, its question, the roles and the clock, with a dot for everyone who joined.
Each phone: the same step, a note, and “I’m ready”.

When the incident method fits

Pick it for a peer group that meets regularly and takes turns: one person brings the case, another leads, and next time it is the other way round. The method needs a case with a concrete moment in it, such as a conversation that went wrong or a decision made under pressure.

It fits less well when the question is a broad dilemma with no moment to tell. Help the case owner find the moment first: when did you last feel this? That moment is the incident.

Leading it, step by step

The question and the incident. Help the case owner get the question into one sentence. Then they tell the moment, and your one hard job in the whole session comes: stopping them, kindly, before they say how it ended.

Clarify. Facts only: who was there, what was said, what happened first. A question that starts with “why did you” is analysis in disguise; ask the group to keep it for the next step.

Analysis. The group talks about what is going on, and the case owner only listens. In a room it helps if they turn their chair a little away; online they mute. Listening without answering is the part of the method people remember.

Alternatives. Everyone writes first what they would do, so nobody echoes the person before them. Then each says it briefly.

Response, insights, reflection. Only now does the case owner tell what happened, or what they will do. The group asks to understand and does not debate. Then each person names one insight about themselves, and you close by looking at the session itself.

Three things to watch

  • The ending leaks. A case owner who is asked the right question will start to tell it. Interrupt early and name the rule again; the group’s analysis is worth more while it is blind.
  • Advice arrives in the analysis. “I would just” belongs two steps later. Say so, and ask what the speaker sees happening in the incident.
  • The case owner defends. If they answer every remark, the group stops being honest. The listening rule protects the case owner as much as the group.

What is said here stays here

An intervision group works on trust, and that is an agreement between people: say it aloud at the start. What the screen adds is small and plain. After you close the session kringo keeps nothing that was written, only numbers such as how long each step ran. If you download the summary, the notes are in your hands, and the agreement of the group covers them too.

Where it comes from

Jeroen Hendriksen describes the incident method in Intervisie bij werk en opleiding, the book many Dutch peer groups work from. You will find versions with fewer steps; ours keeps the ending back until the group has analysed and named its alternatives. The step names and questions on the screen are our wording.

Other methods